Return hubs: 49 organisations call on the EU to protect people’s rights, not outsource them
Joint Statement on the Announcement of an Agreement Between Five EU Countries and Rwanda
We, 49 human rights, humanitarian and civil society organisations from 15 countries, firmly reject plans to set up so-called "return hubs" outside the EU.
Today Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and The Netherlands formally presented their deportation centre in Rwanda.
We (49 signatories from 15 countries) strongly oppose these policies. The announcement today outlines a new phase of harmful externalization policies. Enabled by the new EU Return Regulation, these plans allow people without a right to stay in the EU to be sent to countries with which they have no connection at all. These policies shift people, and responsibility for their safety and rights, beyond the reach of European courts. No choice of partner country, legal guarantees or institutional oversight can eliminate the fundamental risks associated with ’’return hubs’’.
Some Member States are rebranding these “hubs” to ‘welcome centres’ or ‘opportunities’ for people on the move. This is a euphemism that masks forced removal and is a low in a policy of deliberately stripping people of their rights. People will be removed to these deportation centres against their will, often after years in Europe, to a country they may have never lived in, without family, networks or meaningful prospects.
It signals that Member States accept the inhumane treatment of the most vulnerable, people already living at the margins of society, in return for a deterrence goal that evidence clearly suggests they will not reach. Such cruel measures drive people into further insecurity, encouraging dangerous onward movements and creating new opportunities for exploitation and smuggling networks. This is not a hypothetical risk: there is already a precedent. When Israel deported people to Rwanda and Uganda , they were promised legal status and safety. But research indicate that many were driven onto dangerous onward journeys and into the hands of trafficking networks.Rebranding such arrangements does not change their reality: they are forced transfers pushing people outside of the EU’s legal jurisdiction, into a country that cannot guarantee people’s rights.
Rwanda: no protection, no independent oversight
The recently adopted Return Regulation only allows agreements with countries that respect international human rights standards and the prohibition of refoulement. Rwanda fails this test. Austria’s own asylum authority, in its country information on Rwanda, reports torture in detention, arbitrary arrests and impunitywithin the security services. In 2023, the UK Supreme Court found areal risk of refoulement, noting that people sent to Rwanda under the earlier Israeli deal were regularly moved on covertly to Uganda. In Rwanda, courts are not independent of the government, security forces arrest and detain people arbitrarily without due process, often without charge, complaints of ill-treatment are routinely disregarded. and the country has not demonstrated an ability to ensure fair procedures and adequate protection for people forcibly transferred from another country. Due to their involvement with M23, the United States have very recently issued sanctions against the Rwandese Ministry of Defence.
Above all, it remains unclear how oversight could work. The Return Regulation requires anindependent monitoring mechanism of the agreement or arrangement itself only where onward removals are foreseen, but this is not enough. Monitoring is only effective if violations can be stopped and current legislation does not clarify what happens when violations fall outside of the scope of the agreement or arrangement. Even within the EU, monitoring mechanisms have failed to stop border violence.. Where the EU has neither jurisdiction nor enforcement powers, a monitoring mechanism on paper changes nothing.
By relying on third countries to take on its protection obligations, the EU makes itself dependent on non-EU states, enabling third countries to leverage migration in line with their own political agenda. At the same time, such agreements, negotiated amid deep power asymmetries, shift responsibility onto countries that already host more refugees with far fewer resources. They reduce African agency and erode the promise of an equal EU–Africa partnership. By placing its own return agenda above the priorities African countries have recently set out, the EU undermines its credibility as a trusted partner.
Frontex: lack of accountability for rights violations
The Commission’s newly proposed Frontex Regulation would allow the agency to support returns in third countries, including a possible role in implementing “return hubs”, subject to an EU agreement. Frontex currently still operates with a de facto lack of accountability: unclear responsibilities between the agency and Member States have long prevented effective judicial accountability. Instead of addressing these failures, the new proposal removes the current obligation to assign at least one Fundamental Rights Monitor to each operation. Frontex would become more powerful, but not more accountable.
The risks associated with “return hubs” are not implementation failures but are the very purpose of the model. We as civil society call on Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands to abandon plans to establish the so-called ’’return hub’’ in Rwanda and to not transfer people to countries with which they have no meaningful connection. Instead, EU Member States should uphold their international obligations and provide durable solutions with sufficient resources to give people a real chance to become full members of society. These are the values the EU is based on, and we encourage the EU to live up to them.
Décryptage des politiques migratoires européennes